Over the Thanksgiving holiday, a number of jurisdictions across the country, including some in major metropolitan areas like Chicago, held what is known as a “no refusal weekend.” This law enforcement tactic has been implemented cautiously in some jurisdictions on certain dates thought to have particularly high rates of driving under the influence. But, no refusal weekends have been ethically criticized, and anyone picked up for drunk driving has the same right to stage a legal DUI defense.
Just what is a no refusal weekend?
Like other states, Virginia has an implied consent statute that makes it illegal to refuse a BAC chemical test if, based on probable cause, you have been lawfully arrested by a police officer on suspicion of driving under the influence of alcohol. If you refuse to take such a BAC test, you may be subject to certain legal consequences, including the suspension of your driver’s license.
Despite the repercussions, many drivers still choose to refuse the BAC test. According to a 2012 study from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, nationwide between 21 and 25 percent of those arrested for drunk driving refuse a BAC test. Many of those who took a BAC test ultimately defeat charges by staging a DUI defense, and many of those who refused the test are nonetheless convicted. But a significant number of drivers believe that refusing the BAC test, although it carries consequences of its own, will help them defeat the more serious DUI offense.
The no refusal weekend is a controversial tool being put into place by law enforcement agencies fed up with BAC test refusals. Normally, once a driver refuses a BAC test, the police must respect that refusal and cannot force a test.
However, while a driver can refuse to take a standard BAC test, the driver cannot legally refuse a search warrant for a blood or breath sample issued by a judge. Even in states that do not permit officers to use physical force to obtain a breath or blood sample, refusal of a BAC test pursuant to a warrant could mean serious contempt charges.
In a no refusal weekend, police contact judges and request a warrant for every DUI suspect who refuses a BAC test. Given the rise of mobile technology, these warrant requests can be made remotely and any warrants that are issued can be rapidly delivered electronically to a smartphone or tablet device.
At least 30 states, including Virginia, have authorized the use of no refusal initiatives. Not all of them actually conduct no refusal campaigns, and among those that do, it is often only for a limited time period during which drinking is thought to be particularly common.
No refusal policies have some vehement critics, including the American Civil Liberties Union, which says they violate drivers’ Fourth Amendment rights and also raise serious questions about medical privacy.
Facing drunk driving charges? Contact a Virginia DUI defense lawyer
Whatever the circumstances of your arrest and BAC testing, if you are facing drunk driving charges, you need a strong legal defense. Talk to a Virginia DUI defense attorney today to explore your legal options.
At Lawrence, Smith & Gardner, your satisfaction is our priority! See for yourself what our clients have to say about working with us.
Dear Mr. Brillantine and Mr. Smith,
Thank you so much for your time and effort in the past several weeks. I am forever grateful for your help! Thank you.- Previous Client
Dear Mr. Smith,
I just wanted to drop you a note to express my thanks and appreciation for your professional and courteous help and service. The efficient way you and your staff handled my case, resulted in less anxiety for me.- Previous Client
Dear Mr. Smith,
We just want to thank you for all your help in our son’s recent traffic case. Things were looking extremely bleak. However, thanks to your knowledge of the law, persistence, ability to talk to people, hard work and grace … What a relief it has been. We also appreciate the courtesy and professionalism of your wonderful staff.- Previous Client
I am consumed with awe for your legal maneuvering to assist me in court yesterday. Thank you for making it possible for me to continue with my life.- Previous Client
To Ron Smith,
I just wanted to extend my gratitude to you for representing me earlier this month when I went back to court to obtain my restricted license. I appreciate the courtesy and professionalism from you and your staff and under no circumstances hope to ever need your services for a serious matter like that again.- Previous Client
Dear Mr. Smith,
Thank you for all your help. Please extend my thanks also to Martin for his patient support of an incoherent client, as well as to Lisa for her many phone calls. Thanks for that usually elusive gift … a second chance.- Previous Client
I can’t thank you enough for everything. If it weren’t for you I would be in a world of hurt today. I owe you so many thanks. If you ever need anything!! Please pass along all my thanks to your staff and co-workers. Please let Lisa I’m so sorry you missed her lunch too. Thanks again Ron you ROCK!- Previous Client
Dear Mr. Smith,
I wanted to tell you how grateful I am for your help with my recent difficult situation. I was amazed at your skill and knowledge of the court system, and appreciative of your insight in these matters. I can look back on this experience as a valuable lesson and continue on with my life. Thank you for giving me that opportunity.- Previous Client